The true crime books of J.R. StranahanArizona edition

Arizona / Reading the investigation record

Robert Fisher: off the Ten Most Wanted list, still wanted

A familiar wanted poster can outlive the list it came from. Robert William Fisher left the FBI's Ten Most Wanted list in November 2021, but the Bureau continues to publish a wanted notice for him. Reading those records together explains the difference.

Read the official notices ↓

The family behind the notice

On the morning of April 10, 2001, an explosion and fire destroyed a home in Scottsdale. Police identified the people found inside as Mary Fisher and her children, Brittney and Robert Jr., known as Bobby. The department's account alleges that their husband and father, Robert William Fisher, killed them and used the home's gas line to conceal the homicides. That is the allegation behind the search, not a verdict reached in his absence.[1][2]

The FBI's June 2002 announcement records two different legal steps. A state warrant issued on July 19, 2001, charged three counts of first-degree murder and arson of an occupied structure. A subsequent federal warrant concerned unlawful flight to avoid prosecution. The announcement then added Fisher to a national publicity list. The warrants and the publicity decision served different purposes, even when they appeared together on one poster.[3]

Cowboy-shaped Old Town Scottsdale welcome sign beside Scottsdale Road and Main Street signs.
Old Town Scottsdale, photographed November 10, 2018. This is a view of the community, not the Fisher home or a location linked to a reported sighting.Public domain. Photograph by Carol M. Highsmith. Carol M. Highsmith Archive, Library of Congress · Image rights record.

What the list does

The FBI describes Ten Most Wanted as a publicity program. Its published criteria include whether nationwide attention could help investigators apprehend a fugitive. The ten places are not a ranking. A name's presence on the list therefore tells readers something about the Bureau's publicity strategy; it does not make the list a complete inventory of everyone still being sought.[4]

Removal also has more than one possible meaning. The FBI's rules distinguish capture, dismissal of the federal process and a determination that a person no longer meets the list's criteria. For Fisher, its historical record gives a removal date of November 3, 2021. A separate FBI media record explicitly says that he remained a fugitive sought by the Bureau after that removal.[4][5]

The current wanted page supplies the most useful check. It continues to identify Fisher as wanted in connection with the alleged murders and arson and directs information to the FBI. Read alongside the removal record, it supports a clear conclusion: leaving the ten-name list was not an announcement of capture or an end to the search. It does not establish where he is, or whether any particular reported sighting was genuine.[2][5]

Photographs have dates, too

In April 2016, the FBI and Scottsdale police released eight age-enhanced images. The announcement identified 1999 as the date of Fisher's last known photograph and described the new images as possible appearances at the time of the release. An age progression is an investigative aid. It is not a photograph of a later encounter, a confirmed sighting or proof of how someone looks today.[6]

That date matters when an image is shared without its original caption. The 2016 announcement discussed Fisher approaching his fifty-fifth birthday. Reposting one of those images years later cannot turn it into a new observation. Readers can compare the original photographs and labeled age progressions on the FBI's own current page, where the images remain attached to the agency's notice and reporting instructions.[6][2]

Follow the current record

Older announcements remain useful for reconstructing the search, but their headlines and reward figures belong to their publication dates. The FBI archive itself warns that material may be outdated. The sound reading order is to establish what an old notice said, check the later change and finish with the current wanted page. That preserves the history without turning an old label into a present fact.[3][4][2]

Sources and references

This article compares dated official announcements with the current wanted notice. It does not reproduce an investigative file or assert a new sighting. References identify the relevant page sections.

  1. Scottsdale Police: persons of interest and homicide case 01-9328Undated; checked October 3, 2026 · Police case summary

    Used for the victims' names and the discovery of the bodies. The page retains an outdated Ten Most Wanted statement; the FBI's later records control the article's account of list membership.

  2. FBI: Robert William Fisher wanted noticeCurrent page checked October 3, 2026 · Official wanted notice

    Lists the allegations, original photographs, age-enhanced images and official tip instructions. This is not a trial judgment.

  3. FBI announces Fisher's addition to Ten Most WantedJune 29, 2002 · Archived FBI announcement

    Documents the 2001 warrants and 2002 publicity decision. Historical reward amounts and list membership are not presented as current.

  4. FBI: Ten Most Wanted Fugitives FAQChecked October 3, 2026 · FBI program explanation and historical register

    Explains the program's purpose, selection, lack of ranking and removal categories; records Fisher's November 3, 2021 removal.

  5. FBI multimedia record: Robert William FisherUndated; checked October 3, 2026 · FBI media record

    Explicitly distinguishes removal from the Ten Most Wanted list from continuing fugitive status. The article links to this record without reproducing its wanted imagery.

  6. FBI releases age-enhanced images of Robert William FisherApril 8, 2016 · Dated FBI announcement

    Explains what the eight 2016 age progressions were intended to show. Their creation date must not be confused with a later sighting.

Wanted status checked against the FBI's current notice on October 3, 2026. Allegations remain attributed. No current reward amount, location or fate is asserted.