The true crime books of J.R. StranahanNew York edition

New York / Inside the court record

The deleted messages that undid the first Neulander verdict

A juror’s phone became evidence after Robert Neulander’s first murder trial. The messages mattered, but so did what was missing. In 2019, New York’s Court of Appeals upheld an order for a new trial because a juror’s outside communications had been followed by repeated falsehoods and selective deletion. The resulting opinion explains why an inquiry into possible bias depends on an honest record.

Read the original court record ↓

The inquiry became part of the problem

The first jury convicted Neulander in April 2015 of murdering his wife and tampering with physical evidence. According to the Court of Appeals, Juror 12 exchanged hundreds of messages about the case and accessed local news websites covering the trial, despite the judge’s repeated instructions. When questioned during deliberations about outside communications, she denied violating those instructions.[1]

After the verdict, an alternate juror supplied an affidavit describing improper conduct. Juror 12 then deleted selected messages she regarded as problematic and presented the remaining exchanges as complete. The prosecution submitted her affidavit and the altered exchanges without being told that material had been removed.[1]

A forensic examination of the phone exposed selective deletion. Her browsing history, however, had been deleted and could not be recovered. Asked about accessing a website that covered the trial, she suggested that she had probably read about cheerleading. The parties agreed that no such article had appeared there during the relevant period.[1]

Exterior of Onondaga County Courthouse in Syracuse
Onondaga County Courthouse in Syracuse, photographed in 2018. A contextual view of the county’s court architecture, not a photograph of Neulander’s jury or trial.Library of Congress, Prints & Photographs Division, photograph by Carol M. Highsmith. July 20, 2018. Public domain. From the archive · Image rights record.

Why concealment mattered

These were findings discussed by the appellate court, not a license to guess at every message or webpage that had disappeared. The missing material limited what the court could reconstruct. At the same time, the demonstrated effort to hide it undermined confidence in the juror’s explanations. Concealment damaged the very process intended to determine whether outside information had affected the trial.[1]

The trial judge recognized misconduct but did not find that it made the trial unfair. The Appellate Division disagreed, and the Court of Appeals affirmed the new-trial order. Its decision stressed the cumulative effect of the communications, deception and destruction of evidence. It did not establish a rule that every stray text or accidental mistake automatically requires a new trial.[1]

The prosecution argued that substantial evidence of guilt outweighed the misconduct. The court rejected that tradeoff. A strong prosecution case did not cancel the accused person’s right to a fair trial before an impartial jury. That principle addressed the legitimacy of the trial process; it was not a declaration that the defendant had been proven innocent.[1]

A new trial was not an acquittal

The distinction is particularly important here because the case continued. Neulander was convicted again after a retrial. In November 2023, the Appellate Division affirmed the May 2022 judgment for second-degree murder and tampering with physical evidence. Applications for leave to appeal were denied in April 2024. The 2019 decision should not be presented as the final outcome of the prosecution.[2][3]

Its lasting lesson is narrower and concrete. Jurors do not lose all contact with ordinary life, but the court must be able to investigate a possible breach of its instructions. A carefully selected set of messages cannot honestly stand in for the whole exchange. Once the record itself was manipulated, assurances that the juror remained impartial could no longer carry the weight the trial judge had placed on them.[1]

Sources and references

Independently researched companion article, written from the linked primary records.

  1. People v. Neulander, 34 NY3d 110October 22, 2019 · Court of Appeals opinion, official corrected text

    Complete official opinion; record locators use printed reporter pages.

  2. People v. Neulander, 221 AD3d 1412November 17, 2023 · Official appellate opinion after retrial

    Affirms the 2022 judgment. See the separate 2024 leave decision below.

  3. People v. Neulander: leave applications deniedApril 26, 2024 · Official Court of Appeals motion disposition

    Dated later procedural status, not a claim about every possible subsequent proceeding.

The 2019 decision required a new trial. The article includes the later conviction and its 2023 affirmance, with April 2024 leave denial, to avoid implying an acquittal.